Across the Western world, Hindu idol immersions have become the subject of heated debate. What has long been a cherished ritual in India has in recent years come under scrutiny in countries like Canada, the United States and parts of Europe. Images of half-submerged idols in lakes or beaches surface online and quickly ignite controversy. Environmentalists warn of pollution when idols are made from plaster of Paris or painted with toxic dyes. Local councils struggle with regulations. Social media amplifies anger, often without context, framing the practice as inherently harmful. Into this climate of suspicion and criticism, Australia offers a different story.
At the heart of this story are communities like Telugu Sandadi, a Sydney-based group that has helped make Parramatta’s Ganesh Festival one of the largest annual celebrations in New South Wales. For its president, Aruna Chandrala, the practice of immersion is inseparable from faith, but it is also inseparable from responsibility. “We use only Eco friendly Clay Ganesha for immersion and also we heavily condemn immersion of plaster of Paris Ganesha’s with colours and so on,” she said.
That statement goes to the core of how Australia has managed to keep the tradition alive without fuelling environmental disputes. Idol immersions here are conducted with permission from councils, in collaboration with temples, and with strict rules about materials. “Telugu Sandadi joins Hindu Temple in Helensburgh which does Clay Ganesha immersion/nimajjanam at Stanwell beach. Permissions are taken from Wollongong Council,” Aruna confirmed.
The process involves far more than the final act of immersion. Teams of volunteers plan for months, from booking venues and arranging logistics to sourcing garlands, preparing food offerings and setting up cultural programs. “Actually so many people from Ganesha team take ownership and feel proud in what they do, booking venue, looking after the logistics, sponsorships, decorations, maha Naivedyam, pooja samagri, garlands, Laddu, Harathi, cultural programs, receiving guests, photography. Clay Ganesha making, bringing Ganesha garu from storage, sending him back on Sunday morning Clay Ganesha Nimajjanam. Mega task and everything went wonderfully despite the weather conditions,” Aruna said.
This effort is anchored by the presence of a striking 15-foot fibreglass Ganesha, brought from Hyderabad by the community. “Our 15ft Ganesha is fitted on the trailer and stays in Sri Venkateswara Temple storage. We only bring him out for Ganesha Festival to Parramatta every year. Devotees receive his blessings one day at Parramatta and one day at Sri Venkateswara Temple, Helensburgh every year,” Aruna explained. The clay idols used for immersion, however, are smaller, hand-sculpted, and designed to dissolve harmlessly in the sea.
The debate abroad often misses these distinctions. In Canada, a recent incident at Wasaga Beach prompted outrage online, with critics questioning how immersions were allowed. Organisers later clarified that permissions had been secured and the idols used were made of bio-dissolvable clay. But the communication gap meant the broader public perceived non-compliance, even where formal approvals existed. The same tensions have played out in the United States, where temples and community organisations generally seek permissions and encourage eco-friendly idols, but still face scrutiny in a political climate where multicultural practices are often closely watched.
The criticisms are not without precedent. In India itself, where the Ganesh Chaturthi festival draws millions of devotees, environmental concerns have been debated for decades. Lakes and rivers have been polluted by plaster idols and chemical dyes. This has led to large campaigns promoting eco-friendly alternatives, from clay idols to symbolic immersions in tanks. Western countries often reference India’s struggles when raising their own concerns, but the scale is very different. Australia’s events are smaller, more regulated, and deeply conscious of the host country’s environmental expectations.
Still, the question remains whether clay idols alone solve the problem. Some environmentalists argue that even clay immersion can disrupt fragile marine ecosystems. Beaches and rivers may face stress if rituals grow larger in scale. From this perspective, the Australian approach is less a final answer and more an ongoing negotiation between tradition and sustainability. Communities emphasise that they are willing to listen and adapt, but they also stress the importance of being able to continue rituals that are central to faith and identity.
That balance is not always easy. In multicultural societies, public space is often contested. A beach used for immersion one day is a leisure ground the next. Large gatherings can test the patience of other community members who may not understand the cultural significance. Online platforms, meanwhile, can turn isolated images into global flashpoints, stripped of context. What might be a permitted, eco-friendly immersion in New South Wales can be framed by critics overseas as evidence of pollution and disregard.
This is why leaders like Aruna believe it is important to tell their story clearly. The pride volunteers take in the ritual, the permissions sought from councils, and the deliberate choice of clay idols are all part of a narrative that rarely cuts through online noise. For devotees, the practice is not about negligence but about reverence. For organisers, the work is not casual but painstakingly structured.
The global debate will not disappear. Far-right groups in Europe and North America have used images of idol immersions to argue against immigration. Progressive voices have sometimes criticised them too, but from an environmental perspective rather than a cultural one. In between are the communities trying to hold on to their traditions while showing they can adapt.
Australia’s model demonstrates how immigrant communities can balance faith with responsibility. Clear rules, cooperation with councils, and a shift to eco-friendly practices have created a framework where the festival thrives without provoking widespread backlash. Whether this model can be replicated elsewhere will depend on local conditions. In Canada, where lakes are more fragile, or in the US, where political tensions run high, the same solution may not be enough.
What the Australian story shows, however, is that adaptation is possible. Faith can continue while the environment is protected. Tradition can survive without clashing with local laws. For a community, this balance is part of the devotion itself. As Aruna put it, the work of bringing, caring for and bidding farewell to Ganesha is a ritual and a responsibility.
Support independent community journalism. Support The Indian Sun.
Follow The Indian Sun on X | Instagram | Facebook
Support Independent Community Journalism
Dear Reader,The Indian Sun exists for one reason: to tell stories that might otherwise go unheard.
We report on local councils, state politics, small businesses and cultural festivals. We focus on the Indian diaspora and the wider multicultural community with care, balance and accountability. We publish in print and online, send regular newsletters and produce video content. We also run media training programs to help community organisations share their own stories.
We operate independently.
Community journalism does not have the backing of large media corporations. Advertising revenue fluctuates. Platform algorithms change. Costs continue to rise. Yet the need for credible, grounded reporting in a multicultural Australia has never been greater.
When you support The Indian Sun, you support:
• Independent reporting on issues affecting migrant communities
• Coverage of local and state decisions that shape daily life
• A platform for small businesses and community groups
• Media training that builds skills within the community
• Journalism accountable to readers
We cannot cover everything, but we work to cover what matters.
If you value thoughtful reporting that reflects Australia’s diversity, we invite you to contribute. Every donation helps us maintain the quality and consistency of our work.
Please consider making a contribution today.
Thank you for your support.
The Indian Sun Team
